Organizations- IS, IT and VSM
Information Systems
Information systems (IS) is a set of interrelated components that collect, manipulate and disseminate data and information and provide feedback to meet an objective. It is concerned with the information that computer systems can provide to aid a company, non-profit or governmental organization in defining and achieving its goals. It is also concerned with the processes that an enterprise can implement and improve using information technology. IS professionals must understand both technical and organizational factors, and must be able to help an organization determine how information and technology-enabled business processes can provide a foundation for superior organizational performance. They serve as a bridge between the technical and management communities within an organization.
Information Technology
Information technology (IT) refers to all of the computer based information systems used by organizations and their underlying technologies. It refers to anything related to computing technology, such as networking, hardware, software, the Internet, or the people that work with these technologies. Many companies now have IT departments for managing the computers, networks, and other technical areas of their businesses. IT jobs include computer programming, network administration, computer engineering, Web development, technical support, and many other related occupations. Since we live in the "information age," information technology has become a part of our everyday lives.
Viable Systems Model (VSM)
The VSM is a model created by Stafford Beer that describes what ought to be done for an organization to be viable (i.e. to sustain itself over time). It has been used extensively as a conceptual tool for understanding organizations, redesigning them (where appropriate) and supporting the management of change.
There are three components in it:
· Environment (left oval on the diagram), obviously out of the System, defined as Operations + Management
· Operations (circles in the middle)
· Management (squares and triangles on the right)
The VSM is an embodiment of Ross Ashby’s law of requisite variety. Variety is loosely defined as “the number of different states a system can be in”. The Law of Requisite Variety states that for a system to effectively control another one, it must feature at least as much variety as the one it wants to control.
Environment
The Environment is what the system wants to control, so the system must bear the requisite variety, either genuinely or through attenuation (which means that different states of the Environment are managed through the same response from the System because, from the point of view of the System, they fall into the same “category”). So, in front of each part of the Environment the System wishes to control, there a corresponding Operations part that interacts with it.
Operations
Operations manage parts of the Environment. As these parts may overlap, different Operations sub-systems need to communicate (represented as the big zig zag line between the two circles on the diagram). The VSM is a recursive model, meaning that every operation is supposed to be a VSM in itself. The different Operations sub-systems have to cooperate which might, sometime, require some external help in the form of Management. In the VSM, Operations is named “System 1″.
Management
The Management sub-systems are Systems 2, 3, 3*, 4 and 5 with the following roles:
System 2 is in charge of all the signaling between Operations and System 3.
System 3 manages the relations between different Operations sub-systems and resolves any residual conflicts that may not have been resolved between the System 1 themselves. In VSM speech, it’s said to absorb any residual variety not managed by Operations.
System 3* (three-star) is an audit system onto Operations.
System 4 is the foreseeing sub-system in charge of anticipating the future of the Environment as a whole to ensure the VSM will evolve accordingly. Operations are mainly in charge of the present of the Environment parts they’re dealing with and of the Future of their part (since VSM being recursive they have their own sub-system 4).
System 5 is the ethos of the whole VSM, the policy, what defines the strategy of the whole.
Usage of VSM
Mainly, there are two possible usages:- To define the structure of an organization, the VSM being a template against which a real organization may be designed.
- To audit model where an existing organization is assessed against the model to see where some sub-systems could be lacking, possibly impeding viability of the whole, or where parts of the organization may not fit the VSM in which case these parts can be candidates for removal.
On a more pragmatic level, the overall structure of VSM shows that a viable organization is one where operational entities are autonomous with respect to what they have to manage in the environment, yet following an overall strategy defined at global System 5 level.
Communications between Operations need to exist to ensure coordination and someone must be in charge of coordinating the whole (System 3). Time is taken into account by keeping an eye on the future (System 4) and informing the strategy and/or the management of Operations (System 3) where deemed necessary.
The other side of the coin showed by VSM is that any central authority trying to control everything from the top to down is doomed to fail because it will violate the law of requisite variety. The Environment won’t be properly matched by the variety of the system and so the overall viability is at risk.